I’ve been making progress on Franken’s book. Though it’s not slow reading by any means, I’ve been having trouble finding the time to sit down and focus on it. I got a couple tires put on my car today and, while waiting, took the opportunity to knock out a few chapters. One passage in particular really got me.
Most politicians stretch the truth here and there - especially in the name of winning an election. This should be no surprise. But Franken cites one particular stretch spoken by our Commander in Chief that takes the cake. I quote from page 292-293 of Lies (and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them):
Here’s the joke. This is from a June 7, 2002, speech in Iowa. But he’s told it on at least thirteen different occasions.
I remember campaigning in Chicago and one of the reporters said, “Would you ever deficit spend?” I said, “Only – only – in times of war, in times of economic insecurity as a result of a recession, or in times of national emergency.” Never did I dream we’d have a trifecta.
[insert some text explaining how the joke got laughs in several states]
To me the joke is not as funny as the fact that it’s based on a lie. He never said he’d allow a deficit, “only in times of war, in times of economic insecurity as a result of a recession, or in times of national emergency.” He’d never said anything remotely like it during the campaign.
Here, Franken describes how the White House had no record of Bush ever saying this in any state, how Ari Fleischer was “hopping mad” that any investigation was made, and how Karl Rove told Fleischer to let this one slide.
The kicker here is Franken’s footnote to Rove’s comment to Fleischer. It reads:
Funnily enough, one candidate had said something about a war, or a recession, or a national emergency being an acceptable reason for running a deficit. It wasn’t Bush, though. Or Nader. It was Al Gore, who said at the Economic Club of Detroit on May 8, 1998: “Barring an economic reversal, a national emergency, or a foreign crisis, we should balance the budget this year, next year, and every year.”
I’m not saying Bush necessarily copped Gore’s comment or that he never indeed did say it (hey, the White House might have made an honest mistake and lost all record of Bush’s version of the statement), but the two statements seem a little too similar to be unrelated. And since Gore said it in 1998 and Bush said it in 2002, my instincts tell me it’s safe to assume that Gore said it before Bush. This, of course, does not mean Gore thought of it himself either. Maybe he copped it from another speaker. I don’t know. But it is mighty odd…
Can we do some kind of LexisNexis search for all instances of this statement and any variation of it?