I got the new Foo Fighters double album. Yes yes, I know it’s “mainstream” rock and I’m not supposed to talk about bands on this site that anyone else knows about for fear of losing my indie cred, but damn, that Dave Grohl can write a catchy rock n roll song. I’ll concede that some of the lyrics are corny: “this is the last song that I will dedicate to you” doesn’t really do a whole lot for me. But overall, it’s a good batch of songs.
CD 1 is all rock-out. CD 2 is all acoustic folky stuff. When I found out that the Foo Fighters were releasing a double album, I thought of something I read about Kurt Cobain before he offed himself. He wanted to release the Nirvana Unplugged cd as a double album together with a compilation of live concert tracks. Seems he never got to follow through with that idea. Instead, Krist and Dave got to sift through hours and hours of tracks by themselves, the results of which formed the Muddy Banks of the Wishkah live album (1996).
I don’t think it’s fair to keep the Foo Fighters and Dave Grohl in the shadow of Nirvana, though. Any similarities could be completely coincidental. Foo Fighters ought to be looked at independent of anything Nirvana ever recorded.
Thus, I direct you to Pitchfork’s review, which actually makes some good points, the best being:
"Virginia Moon" allows Grohl to croon gently into the night sky, singing lullabies to an army of dudes driving home from their girlfriend's houses in their Honda Accords.
Umm, hi, that’s me.
Unfortunately, the Pitchfork author can’t avoid making the usual Nirvana references and also manages to throw in Dave’s side projects:
Nirvana felt wobbly, fragile, and fleeting, Queens of the Stone Age pound deranged, Probot are full-on bananas: The Foo Fighters are strong, neat, and clean. So we wonder: Can a steady, hard-working everydude from northern Virginia make transcendent art? Sure. Does Dave Grohl? Sometimes.
I think that’s a little harsh, and more than a little pointless. Since when is “transcendent art” the goal? The goal is good music, and I don’t think transcendent art has anything to do with that.